Air-Cooled vs Liquid-Cooled Laser Welding for Bellows: How to Choose

Application note · Cooling configuration

The duty cycle decides the cooling method, not the badge on the datasheet. A 1.5 kW source that emits for a few seconds in every ten needs a fan; the same badge on a machine that welds all shift needs a chiller.

1.5 kWmains draw, air-cooled bench
75–450 Waverage power, four builds
Multi-metreenvelope on gantry builds

The duty cycle is the real question

A QCW source publishes two power figures and buyers read the larger one. Peak power, which scales with the build, decides whether the beam keys the metal. Average power, always a small fraction of it, decides what the cooling circuit carries.

The gap between them is not a defect. It is why the process works on thin wall: a short pulse at high peak closes the seam, and the gap before the next pulse lets the convolution stay straight. Pulse width runs 0.05 to 50 ms at up to 5 kHz.

So the question is not how much power the machine carries. It is how many minutes of each hour the source spends emitting, and how many hours in a row it does that.

Two patterns reach the same order book and they are thermally opposite. An instrument shop changes fixtures every few hours and idles in between. A manifold supplier welds one part family to a fixed takt for months, three shifts deep, expecting part one thousand to match part one.

Continuous operation changes what the cabinet is asked to do. Draw is 1.5 kW, and what a machine draws it eventually rejects into the room it stands in. In an intermittent week the bay absorbs that between runs. In a continuous week the same bay absorbs it all shift, and its temperature becomes a variable nobody priced.

That is where the badge stops being informative. The 43-second run shows one seam from start to finish, short enough to time with a stopwatch.

What forced air actually costs you

On the bench machine, fan cooling is a complete system rather than a compromise. Two fan panels on the rear face pull shop air through the cabinet. No chiller, no coolant, no pump, no water-quality routine, no hose across the floor. The enclosure is a single floor-standing cabinet, small enough to sit in a service bay.

What you pay for that is a dependence. The room becomes part of the cooling system: its temperature, its dust and the space behind the cabinet all sit in the thermal path.

Air stops being enough at a predictable set of conditions:

  • The bay is at its hottest and the cabinet is against a wall, in a corner, or beside something that already radiates.
  • The run is unbroken for hours, with no fixture change long enough for the cabinet to shed what it collected.
  • Grilles and filters are carrying a season of shop dust nobody has looked at since installation.

None of those is a fault. They are the conditions the fan was sized against, exceeded by the way the machine is used. The failure mode is at least honest: a stopped fan announces itself as a temperature alarm.

Rear of a bellows welding machine showing two white cooling fan panels installed in a production workshop
Two fan panels are the entire cooling system on the bench machine. The rear face is the only place source and cabinet heat can leave, which is why clearance behind the cabinet and the temperature of the air entering those panels belong on your site drawing.

When water earns the plumbing

Water cooling appears on the 4-axis gantry, the cantilever and the 5-axis machines, with sources in the multi-kilowatt class and work areas measured in metres. Those platforms exist because a source of that class, sweeping a table with an A-axis turning ±400°, cannot shed its heat into a working bay.

Dual temperature means two circuits with two setpoints, one for the source and one for the optics and head. They are regulated apart because the two do not want the same temperature, and each should hold its own band over a long run.

Three things change, and only one is technical.

  • Utilities. A chiller or plant circuit, pumps, and a person who owns water quality. The electrical supply stops being the interesting half of the list.
  • Floor space. The chiller needs a home, the hoses need a route, and service access has to survive whatever gets parked in front of it.
  • Maintenance interval. Coolant, filters, hoses, fittings, pump: a schedule with dates on it rather than a glance when something looks wrong.

What water buys is headroom. Heat leaves through a circuit instead of through the building, so the bay’s afternoon temperature stops setting the limit and the shop’s worst week stops being a variable in your leak rate.

On a three-shift manifold line that trade is worth the plumbing. On a bench welding prototypes, it is a chiller nobody asked for.

What changes when you move from air to water

On this machine familyForced air, bench machineDual-temperature water, gantry / cantilever / 5-axis
Source classBench class, quoted per buildMulti-kilowatt
Where the heat goesInto shop air, through two rear fan panelsInto a chiller or plant circuit, two regulated loops
Work envelope500 × 400 mm, customisableMulti-metre, set by the gantry
Utilities on site220 or 380 V ±5 %, 1.5 kWSame supply class, plus chiller, pumps, water quality
Ambient sensitivityHigh: the room is the heat sinkLow: the circuit is the heat sink
Maintenance loadGrilles, filters, rear clearanceCoolant, filters, hoses, fittings, pump
Best fitIntermittent runs, mixed families, tight floor spaceLong runs, large parts, multi-shift output

Travel speed, 1–10 m/min, and spot size, 0.2–2 mm, are identical on both sides. Nothing in that table is a weld-quality row; every difference is a facility difference, which is why your building settles the argument.

Before you specify water, check three things on site

Water is usually specified ahead of a production plan. Three observations on the floor decide whether the plan is real.

  1. Air temperature at the back of the cabinet, late in the busiest shift. Not the wall thermostat. If the incoming air is already near the bay’s high for the day, forced air has less margin than the specification implies, and the answer is a different position or a different platform.
  2. The longest unbroken run anyone can document. Not shift length: the longest stretch in which the source keeps emitting with no gap for a fixture change. If nobody can answer, treat the pattern as intermittent until production says otherwise.
  3. Who owns the water. Whether a chiller or plant circuit exists, whether there is a drain and floor space for one, and whether anyone already maintains water systems. A no to the last question turns water cooling into a recurring task without an owner, and that surfaces later as downtime.

Gas belongs on the same walk-round. Shielding gas is set at a proportional valve inside the cabinet and sits in the recipe beside peak power, so the supply has to reach the machine before the first sample.

Proportional gas valve and pneumatic fittings inside the cabinet of a bellows laser welding machine
Shielding gas is a number in the recipe, not a valve somebody opens by feel. The proportional valve and its fittings sit inside the cabinet, which is what makes gas flow repeatable between operators and across a shift.
Bellows laser welding machine installed in a production workshop with clear space behind the cabinet
An installation is decided by what is behind the cabinet, not what is in front of it. A bay like this one shows the clearance the rear air path needs, and the same drawing is where a chiller and its hoses would have to fit if you specified water.

Where this advice does not apply

Some problems look like cooling questions and are not.

  • Thick section. If the joint needs deep penetration in plate, no cooling choice turns a 1.5 kW QCW build into a multi-pass machine. Source class is the limit, not the heat sink.
  • Fit-up and tooling. When scrap is dominated by burrs at the convolution root, or a fixture that lets the part move, the circuit is irrelevant. Fix the tooling first.
  • Parts that are not bodies of revolution. A chuck welds a circle. Flat or asymmetric joints need different kinematics, and axis count is the decision to make.
  • Very low volume. Below a few hundred units a year, a skilled TIG operator with a good fixture can be the cheaper route. Laser economics come from repeatability at volume, not from one perfect part.

In all four cases the cooling question still exists. It is just not the first one worth answering.

Questions buyers actually ask

Can the air-cooled machine weld 0.3 mm bellows for a whole shift?

Wall thickness is not the limit here, duty is. A 150 W average source has enough control at 0.3 mm to reach full penetration without burn-through. What it is not built for is continuous emission in a bay that is already hot at the end of the afternoon shift. If that is your week, the honest answer is the water platform.

Does water cooling give a better weld?

No. The chiller protects the machine. The joint is decided by peak power, pulse width, repetition rate, travel speed, focus, gas and how steadily the fixture holds the part concentric to the chuck. Water changes how long those settings hold, not whether they are right.

Can an air-cooled machine be converted to water later?

Treat the two as platforms, not an upgrade path. The water-cooled machines bring larger sources, multi-metre envelopes and more axes; the circuit follows from that, not from a kit. If large parts and three shifts are likely within two years, specify the platform now.

What does each option demand in maintenance?

Air asks for clear grilles and filters, clearance behind the cabinet and a fan that still turns. Water asks for coolant condition, filter changes, hose and fitting inspection, pump service and water quality. The second list is longer and needs a named owner.

Write your duty cycle down before you ask for a quote. Hours per week, longest unbroken run, parts per shift, and the air temperature behind the cabinet on your worst afternoon. Send that with a drawing and we will price both machines against the same numbers.

Talk to application engineering →